To Choose Is Enough

In Pamela Z’s performances, one can hear an entire history of late 20th-century music: the echoes of Milton Babbitt’s Philomel, Steve Reich’s tape loops, Laurie Anderson’s reflections and electronic voice distortions, the trans-like repetition of Meredith Monk’s primal chanting, David Lang’s melodic contours, and, with only a slight stretch of imagination, a distant voice from a Robert Ashley opera. However, you’d be better off immersing into the present.

The program of Pamela Z’s concert on August 18, at the DiMenna Center, at Time: Spans Festival did not include any premieres. The most recent piece, Flock (2024), seemed to sonically emerge from its earlier avian-themed counterpart, Syrinx (2003). Yet no version of her works, spanning over three decades, is exactly repeated. The last piece in the program, Scared Song, was originally created as a studio arrangement for Meredith Monk’s 2012 tribute CD, Monk Mix. For the album release party, Z made a live version, rearranging programmed sounds into real-time voice processing; this was the one we heard now in 2026, or was it really?

Other Rooms on the surface seemed to have changed little since its New York premiere at Roulette in 2018. Yet there were at least two differences; most notably, the choreography and, by extension, the sounds generated by gesture-based sensors in the final part. Also, the prepared piano “quotations” that were previously searching for the right volume and location were now seamlessly integrated into the fabric of sounds to create a refined version of electronic polystylism. The piece is constructed from samples of the speaking voice of playwright Paul David Young, taken from an interview Z recorded while making her larger work, Memory Trace. His statements may seem random, but that night, I imagined them as descriptions of artistic process. “You just pick up wherever you left off, as if you never stopped talking,” is a writer’s ideal state. “Am I actually remembering it or am I constructing it?” reminds me of the origins of Laurie Anderson’s narratives, as described in Alexander Reed’s recent account about her Big Science. Could Young’s words also be interpreted as artists’ statements? They could, if such a thing existed, as Declaratives in the first person explain. “I would like to think that the art itself is enough of a statement,” Z states; as this credo emerges from layers of distorted phrases and eventually falls apart, one also learns that “to think is enough.”

Photo by classicasobi

In the world of electronics and motion controllers, where the invention of new ways of sound manipulation is often sufficient to be considered a creative work, the experience of a meaningful, multidimensional sensory space remains rare. Z’s vitality and well-rehearsed spontaneity certainly enlivened the festival’s increasingly diversifying, but still European-dominated programming. Among acoustic nights, my favorite this year was AMOC’s performance of Salvatore Sciarrino’s Stupori, appropriately combined with Michael Hersch’s Carrion-Miles to Purgatory. The first one – six readable silences based on heterogeneous texts where baritone, in Sciarrino’s own characterization, “plays the starring role, with excesses of restlessness, almost bordering on dramatically acted scenes.” The second – thirteen pieces after texts of Robert Lowell, which “simply live in the score” with violin and cello enacting their restrained intensity. 

It’s been 11 years since my fear of missing out on New York’s new music life, previously dormant in summer, began to peak in the middle of August. Among 12 concerts at Time: Spans this year, the most important was making the right choice.

Erlena Dlu

193 secular sacred lines

The performance of David Lang’s the national anthems at the Met museum, appropriately, was the first time I celebrated the 4th of July – to mark my 16th year since arriving in New York and the longest time I have ever lived in one place. I was introduced to his music in 2010 in a graduate seminar called “Music After 1945” through the piece Cheating, Lying, Stealing. Its irregular pounding rhythms seemed too aggressive, yet the brief moments of fleeting beauty and the humility expressed in the program note stuck with me.

Then came The Mile-Long Opera: a biography of 7 o’clock, which has, since 2018, remained one of the most memorable experiences. At that time, unassumingly, I called Lang’s music “simple, repetitive, deeply human,” and every following piece of his confirmed that description. This was followed by The Little Match Girl Passion, paired with Morton Feldman’s Rothko Chapel at a concert in YIVO under the label “secular sacred music” – a concept I’ve been exploring in my endlessly forthcoming book. In a post-show talk, Lang explained that the prolonged quietude and repetition – a sonorous landscape that sprawls without changes – is meant to prepare a listener for an important statement, such as the viola’s quasi-Hebraic melody in Rothko Chapel. (Lang develops the idea of secular sacred music in a thought-provoking essay published ahead of the performance of his poor hymnal.)

Proto by clarionchoirandorchestra

Experiencing the subtle beauty of the national anthems in a large museum gallery with many random listeners hissing, coming and going, might seem irritating. Yet, standing right next to the musicians, I could still enjoy the tranquility and familiar harmonies which, for the first time, reminded me of Arvo Pärt. Lang’s focus in this piece is not on the music, but on the idea, a common theme expressed in the texts of 193 nations, that freedom is fragile and easily lost. Carefully rendered by Clarion Choir and Catalyst Quartet, the piece sounded like a psalm, or even a prayer, pleading for the recovery of human wisdom. The introspection and reevaluation of what is essential – an antidote to traditional fireworks – that we so desperately need today.

Erlena Dlu

Photo by Erlena Dlu

©2026 by Extended Techniques. All Rights Reserved.

No Winter, No War: The Transfixing Power of Mōdraniht

On June 1-3, the Vienna Festival (Wiener Festwochen) hosted three nights of Mōdraniht. Songs of Winter War – the third experimental opera in the environmental trilogy by the creative collective Opera Aperta. The show had previously been performed at O. Festival in Rotterdam on May 26 and premiered on May 10 in Kyiv, where the company’s rehearsal space has since been destroyed by a Russian missile attack. To create this production, composers Roman Grygoriv and Illia Razumeiko traveled to Northern Spain, the Carpathian Mountains, and Uzbekistan to document winter solstice rituals and the present condition of the dried-up Aral Sea. 

The previous two productions in the trilogy were quite remarkable – Chornobyldorf received the Royal Philharmonic Society’s award for the best opera, running against Kaija Saariaho’s Innocence, and GAIA-24. Opera del Mondo received the 2025 Music Theatre Now Award. Yet Mōdraniht is certainly more original, deeper, and overall, much stronger both musically and dramaturgically. The music amplifies the emotional charge of visual sequences in just the right way; moreover, it could easily exist as a stand-alone piece, apart from those moments when it dissolves into silence, quotations from the classics, and the ringing of cow bells. The timing between unexpected scene changes is perfectly calculated. A Richard Foreman play, but with meaning?

The meaning was clarified in Razumeiko’s introductory remarks. (Neither winter nor war explicitly appear in the production itself, except for the artist-led Q&A session with the audience, in the middle of the show.) Switching between English and German, to engage both international guests and locals, he explained the origin of some visuals and props: the ships in the desert demonstrate the results of Russian colonization – the draining of the Aral Sea, the injured face belongs to a recently discharged Ukrainian veteran, and the partially destroyed pianos symbolize those that were looted by the Red Army soldiers from Austria in 1945. These facts made the abstract production that followed feel timely, yet I imagined its existence without any explanations, as the aesthetic quality of the piece can certainly ensure its timelessness.

Photo by Viktor Andriichenko

By all counts, the artists of Opera Aperta are superhumans. The cast consists of professionals trained as singers (operatic or folk), dancers, string or percussion players, but each has mastered the drums, strings, pianos, and other instruments and objects. With any and all parts of their bodies, they play a mesmerizing sequence à la Boulez’s Piano Notations, where every note, tone cluster, and silence musically make perfect sense. (The positions include leaning perpendicularly to play with the crown of the head on a piano positioned sideways, and doing push-ups while stretched along the keyboard, which is possible only because of the enormous strength in Marichka Shtyrbulova’s tiny body.) Mingling with the audience, the performers can create a stereophonic sound by jumping incessantly for over 15 minutes while wearing 350 bells, ranging in size from an apple to a watermelon. They can also flawlessly sing six-part polyphony while all piled up on top of each other, in upside-down or sideways positions that seem to defy the existence of gravity. (The singing happens after the bells episode, and no one seems to be out of breath.)

Mōdraniht, however, is not merely a collection of startling effects or a show-off of improbable skills. It’s a work of high art that leaves you startled, with eyes wide open and many questions.  (Is it really over? Why do the lights project “The End” while the music is still playing, one artist is still lying on the stage, and no one comes out for a bow to greet the puzzled, hesitantly clapping audience? And, more importantly, when are they coming to New York?)

Erlena Dlu

Photo by Viktor Andriichenko

©2026 by Extended Techniques. All Rights Reserved.

24 Memorable Music Events in NYC in 2024

While preparing this list, we realized we missed so many amazing NYC music events in 2024! Nevertheless, here is the best of what we’ve seen and want to remember. As always, with no intention of ranking, in reverse chronological order. (Although with a definite preference for 1, 9, and 23.)

Photo by Bogdan Grytsiv

  1. “Suppose Beautiful Madeline Harvey,” a Richard Foreman play by Object Collection (La MaMa Experimental Theatre Club, December 13-22) 
  2. David Lang’s poor hymnal (Lincoln Center, December 21) [Here is David Lang’s thought-provoking interpretation of the work’s genre.]
  3. El Niño: Nativity Reconsidered (The Cathedral of Saint John the Divine, December 19)
  4. TRIO with special guests: Ikue Mori, Ingrid Laubrock, Sylvie Courvoisier, and Lotte Anker (The Stone, December 13) [As well as all other Lotte Anker’s appearances throughout the year. Her thoughts on improvisation are certainly worth a read.]
  5. Remembering Gheorghe Costinescu (Rutgers Presbyterian Church, December 7)
  6. The New Virtuoso: Borders (Carnegie Hall, October 30)
  7. The music of Victoria Polevá (Faust Harrison Pianos, October 29)
  8. 40th Anniversary of John Zorn’s Cobra (Roulette, October 11)
  9. Indra’s Net by Meredith Monk (Park Avenue Armory, October 1-6)
  10. The TIME: SPANS festival, especially its beginning, middle, and end. (DiMenna Center, August 10-24) [See one of the best shows reviewed here.]
  11. Natural Studies by thingNY (The Brick, August 15-17)
  12. Michael Foster / John Blum / Brandon Lopez / Joey Sullivan Quartet (Prospect Series, June 7) 
  13. Sally Gates, Zoh Amba, Brian Chase (Sisters, August 12) [As well as all other Zoh Amba’s appearances throughout the year. Here is an inspiring interview with her by the Roulette Tapes.]
  14. John Zorn: New Masada Quartet (Roulette, May 24)
  15. Weston Olencki + TAK Ensemble (Roulette, May 21)
  16. Foreign Experiences: An Opera by Robert Ashley (Roulette, May 9 – 11)
  17. Ensemble Connect Up Close: Electronic Etudes (Carnegie Hall, May 6)
  18. LONG PLAY FESTIVAL, especially the preview show Claire Chase & JACK Quartet Density 2036, Part XI: Terry Riley (Various venues, May 2-5)
  19. Magda Mayas: Chant (Roulette, April 29)
  20. Hiromichi Sakamoto / Kato Hideki & Zeena Parkins (Brooklyn Music School, February 2)
  21. Improv Nights 2024: A Tribute to Derek Bailey (Roulette, January 25 -27)
  22. Shelley Hirsch: “And So It Was and Was and WaAAass” (Roulette, January 23)
  23. Chornobyldorf: Archeological Opera In Seven Novels (La MaMa Experimental Theatre Club, January 11-21) [Here is our podcast episode about Chornobyldorf and all major operas by the composers Roman Grygoriv and Illia Razumeiko.]
  24. Annual New Year’s Day Poetry Marathon, in particular, the performances by Claire Chase, and Ka Baird with Shelley Hirsch. (St. Mark’s Church, January 1)

Photo by Opera Aperta

12 Memorable Music Events in New York in 2023

NYC music events in 2023 we want to remember, with no intention of ranking, in reverse chronological order.

Photo by Kaitlin
  1. Sun Tracing Magic Special with Ned Rothenberg (reeds) Sylvie Courvoisier (piano) Charmaine Lee (voice) Ches Smith (drums) Sae Hashimoto (percussion) David Watson (bagpipes) Makigami Koichi (voice) Satoko Fujii (piano) kappamaki (trumpet) Erik Friedlander (cello) Zeena Parkins (harps) Ikue Mori (electronics) (The Stone, December 17)
  2. Ensemble Decipher: Cat’s Cradle (Roulette, October 23)
  3. John Zorn at 70 celebrations at Miller Theatre at Columbia University, especially New Masada / Simulacrum (Miller Theatre, October 19)
  4. Fred Frith residency at the Stone, especially Duos and Trios with Fred Frith (home-made instruments, percussion), Ikue Mori (electronics) and Nate Wooley (trumpet) and Quartet with Nava Dunkelman (percussion, voice), Fred Frith (electric guitar, voice), Carla Kihlstedt (violin, voice) and Theresa Wong (cello, voice) (The Stone, October 6 and 11).
  5. Roscoe Mitchell & John McCowen / Beam Splitter and the following improvisation workshop (First Unitarian Congregational Society, Brooklyn Music School September 9 and 10)
  6. John Zorn at 70 at Roulette, especially Part Three: John Zorn, Laurie Anderson, Sean Ono Lennon (Roulette, August 27)
  7. Jazztopad Festival New York, especially 3 sets: 1) Amir ElSaffar, Ole Mathisen, Tomas Fujiwara 2) Ksawery Wójciński and friends (Shift, June 23) and 3) Joanna Duda, Max Mucha, Michał Bryndal, Ksawery Wójciński & Maniucha Bikont, Kirk Knuffke (Barbès, June 25)
  8. La Monte Young And Marian Zazeela: Just Charles. Charles Curtis, cello. (Peter Freeman, Inc., June 4)
  9. Claire Chase Density @ 10, especially Density III and IV (The Kitchen at Westbeth, May 19)
  10. Vicente Atria and Mat Muntz’s “The Vex Collection” and Wet Ink Ensemble (Scholes Street Studio, May 14)
  11. Long Play Festival 2023 | Bang On A Can, especially Meredith Monk’s Memory Game (Pioneer Works, May 5)
  12. Champion, an opera by Terence Blanchard (The Metropolitan Opera, Aril 10 – May 13)

+ 1. Radio 477! Yara Arts Group + Serhiy Zhadan + Anthony Coleman (La MaMa, March 10 – 19)
+ 2. Shockwave Delay: Yoshiko Chuma and the School of Hard Knocks (La MaMa, June 1-11)

If you want to share your thoughts on events you want to remember, please post a comment below.

Video by Alotro Lado